Challenging the new orthodoxy: a critique of SPLISS and variable-oriented approaches to comparing sporting nations

Henry, Ian, Dowling, Mathew, Ko, Ling-Mei and Brown, Phil (2020) Challenging the new orthodoxy: a critique of SPLISS and variable-oriented approaches to comparing sporting nations. European Sport Management Quarterly. pp. 1-17. ISSN 1618-4742

Challenging the New Orthodoxy A Critique of SPLISS and Variable-Oriented Approaches to Comparing Sporting Nations_Brown.pdf - Accepted Version

Download (232kB) | Preview


Research Question: In recent years the comparative sport policy field has become dominated by the ‘SPLISS’ approach developed by De Bosscher and colleagues. While the SPLISS approach has developed important insights into the statistical relationship between key groups of independent variables and indicators of elite sport policy success, nevertheless its attempts to identify and explain both statistical association and causal relationships have significant limitations. The paper thus seeks to address the question of the nature of such strengths and limitations and their implications for theory, policy and practice. Methods: As a review paper it develops a critical evaluation of claims made for the SPLISS approach to variable oriented comparative policy analysis. Results: The paper identifies and focuses on the implications of six key problems for the SPLISS approach, namely: philosophical assumptions and causal variables; the black box problem; internal validity issues; non-equivalence and reliability; the neglect of agency; and misconceptions in the use of mixed methods. Implications: The paper’s findings represent a challenge to the hegemony of this variable-oriented approach and they argue not for replacement or rejection of such an approach, but for recognition of its limitations, and of the opportunities for complementing it with case-driven, qualitative analysis generating causal accounts of policy outcomes.

Item Type: Article
Keywords: sport policy, comparative, methodology, elite sport, sporting nations
Depositing User: Ms Raisa Burton
Date Deposited: 28 Jan 2020 12:57
Last Modified: 28 Jul 2021 03:50
Related URLs: https://www.tan ... 42.2020.1719428 (Publisher URL)

Actions (login required)

Edit Item Edit Item